Mineral Rights, Surface Ownership, Life Estates - Understanding Legal Ownership of Land

Nature of Ownership Interests in Landwhich possess a useful property giving them
By law, property falls into two categories -- realspecial value. An exception would be sand, gravel,
or personal. Real property includes land andlimestone, etc which are normally considered part
whatever is permanently attached to land, foundof the surface estate as is subsurface water.
on it either by nature, (water, trees, or minerals)Minerals are often severed from the surface
or by man (buildings, fences, bridges, roads).estate. Such severance is accomplished with a
Land is an inanimate thing which persons may,conveyance or reservation of the minerals in a
under the law, have different status to the landconveyance. This conveyance or reservation
and the things attached to the land. ie. You canincludes minerals or such substances considered as
own the surface rights, but you sell the timberminerals. This is to include such things as natural
rights to farmer John for 25 years.gas, as it has been often asked by bemused
The nature of the status of the land is fixed bygeologists "Is natural gas a mineral?"
law, and are distinguished as being either aFurther, this conveyance or reservation includes
freehold estate or a non-freehold estate. Freeholdroyalties, bonuses, and rentals.
means ownership without limitations to duration.Determinable or Conditional Fee
Non-freehold would be like farmer John whoThis fee is the same as fee simple estate, but
bought timber rights, that only last 25 years.subject to an automatic termination triggered by
Freehold estates include estates in fee simple,an occurrence or act. Any estate in land may be
determinable or conditional fee, and life estates.granted with conditions or special restrictions. The
Fee Simplenon-performance of the condition, or the
(note: Don't let the word "Fee" confuse you, it is aoccurrence of the event will execute the
legal term, not a charge like a bank fee.)automatic forfeiture of the estate, but until that
Fee simple title is the highest form of estatehappens, the owner enjoys the estate as if it
ownership. It is free of any condition or restriction.were fee simple.
Every estate conveyed is considered a fee simpleAn example of a determinable fee would be the
unless expressly limited. The owner of a feesale from A to B "so long as the Klipsh
simple interest has the exclusive right of its useSynagogue still stands, then to C." Another
and sale.example is a mineral lease which is a determinable
So it is possible that someone owns the surface,fee interest in the mineral estate.
another owns the mineral rights, another theThe owner of a determinable fee has all the rights
royalties to those minerals, another the timber,that a fee simple owner has, but there is always
etc. Each such fee simple owner has the exclusivethe possibility that it may be terminated. If he
ownership free and clear of any condition orsells the estate, the buyer accepts the possibility
restriction.that of termination.
To contrast this case, we examine a deed in aLife Estates
subdivision that is burdened by a home ownersWhere property is granted to an individual for as
association. The homeowner would not have feelong as he lives, and upon his death shall pass to
simple ownership of his estate. It is burdened byanother party, he is the owner of a conventional
the restrictions placed on his deed by the homelife estate. He is called a life tenant of the
owners association.property, with the right of possession, use and all
Surface Estateincome therefrom.
Often referred to as surface rights. It is theStatutory life estates are created automatically
ownership of the surface of the land. It impliesupon the death, intestate, of husband or wife; and
the right that the owner may do whatever hethe surviving spouse becomes a life tenant, with
wishes to the land as far as law permits.the right of possession, use and all income, to one
Mineral Estatethird of the separate property of the deceased,
Often referred to as mineral rights. The mineralwith the remainder to the legal heirs of the
estate of the land includes all unusual organic anddeceased.
inorganic substances forming a part of the soil